I’m a contented atheist. And have been since I was nineteen. However, I was baptized a Catholic, but never practiced until my family moved to Leek in 1956.
A little background. My mother’s family were Irish Catholics. My father’s parents were Methodist. My parents were married at St. Joseph’s Roman Catholic Church, Epsom, Surrey in November 1936. But as I grew up in Congleton (where I was born in 1948), I have only one recollection of ever having stepped inside the Church of St Mary on West Road. I remember my mother once telling me about an incident at the church, maybe when my sister took her First Communion. Apparently, the parish priest told my mother that my father, a Protestant, was not welcome in the church. No ecumenism in those post-war days. So until we moved to Leek in 1956, I can never remember going to Mass.
Things changed after the move to Leek, and we started to attend Mass at St Mary’s Catholic church. I even trained as an altar boy, alongside Michael Oliver (brother of Kevin, whose father kept a sweet shop on Broad Street). Not infrequently I’d accompany one of the priests to say Mass in Ipstones (at a pub there) or St Edward’s Hospital in Cheddleton. I joined the cub scouts, 5th Leek St Mary’s, run by Mr Kelsall, who we called ‘Sir’ instead of ‘Akela’.
The parish priest was Fr Clavin – liked by many who came in contact with him. Fr Thornton was the curate when we moved to Leek, but he was soon replaced by another younger priest, on the left of the photo below. This photo was taken on the occasion of Fr Clavin’s Jubilee (with a young Gerald Grant on the right).
My elder brother Edgar and I were also enrolled in the local Catholic primary school, St Mary’s, on the corner of Broad Street (the A53) and Cruso Street. Being two years older (and three academic years ahead), Edgar attended St Mary’s for just one year. I, on the other hand, continued my education there until July 1960 when I secured a place to attend the Catholic grammar school, St Joseph’s College, in Trent Vale, Stoke-on-Trent, which entailed a round trip of 28 miles. That became my daily term-time routine for the next seven years.
April 1956. I was 7½.
New town, new friends, new school . . . and NUNS!
I think I must have shed a few tears that first day at school. I was so bewildered. I’d never seen a nun before, and they looked so intimidating in their long black habits, white wimples leaving just their faces exposed, and long black veils typical of the Sisters of Loreto, who came to Leek in 1860 to teach children of the parish. The last nuns left in 1980, and their convent behind the church was sold for development.
The headmistress, Mother Michael seemed quite pleasant and welcoming, but she left after about a year. In the four years I spent at St Mary’s my teachers were Mother Bernadine, Mother Elizabeth (who became headmistress) and, in my last year, Mr Smith (the first male teacher at the school). Sister (later Mother) Martin and Mother Vincent de Paul were other teachers who I remember.
My wife still uses a woven needle/pin case that I made during my time at St Mary’s (helped by one of the teachers).
So what’s all this about losing my religion? Well, a few days ago, I posted a query on the closed group Facebook page about Leek to which I belong. I was researching some information (and photographs) for a blog post I intend publishing a little later this year. While my query yielded few photos, I was surprised at the number of people who joined the conversation. And for many, their years at St Mary’s were not the happiest.
I always saw the nuns as quite strict. One of them often used the edge of a steel-edged ruler to rap any miscreant on the knuckles. It didn’t take much to be viewed as a miscreant, as the Facebook commentaries from former pupils indicate.
Some were clearly profoundly unhappy at St Mary’s, others not. Some have recounted being caned in front of the whole school, even for attending a wedding at a non-Catholic church! All in all, I was quite horrified at these memories of what seem like gratuitous violence perpetrated on 5-11 year-olds. The situation for several was so dire, apparently, that they were moved by their parents to another non-Catholic school in the town.
I never saw any canings, or at least I don’t remember the cane being administered. Until some of the Facebook group members mentioned this, it didn’t form part of my memory narrative. The ruler I certainly do remember and was the recipient on at least one occasion.
On the whole, my memories of just over four years at St Mary’s are neither positive nor negative. As one group member stated overnight, we survived. But was that sufficient?
Things have changed. Take a look at the St Mary’s today; it appears to be a thriving and nurturing community.
Corporal punishment was a daily occurrence at St Joseph’s, especially for pupils younger than sixteen. Punishments were meted out almost every lesson, even for slight misdemeanors.
The school, for boys only, had been founded by Irish Christian Brothers in the 1930s. I guess that when I first attended the Brothers were about a fifth of the teaching staff. Or maybe I exaggerate. Certainly walking around in their long black cassocks and dog collars they were a highly identifiable presence who brooked no dissension.
Today the Christian Brothers are no longer associated with St Joseph’s. It’s also co-educational, and has a thriving Sixth Form that attracts students from the wider community, Catholics and non-Catholics alike.
In 1960, the headmaster was Bro. Henry Wilkinson (for a couple of years) and thereafter until I left in 1967, Bro. O’Keefe. Bro. Wilkinson regularly used a tannoy to broadcast to every classroom throughout the school, which was quickly dismantled after O’Keefe took the reins.
Every teacher was permitted to physically punish any pupil, and used a leather strap (apparently manufactured in Ireland), maybe almost 18 inches long, of at least two layers of leather sewed together.
The Brothers had a special pocket in the side of their cassocks to hold the strap. Usually, a boy would hold out one of both hands, palm upwards, and receive maybe a couple of strokes. It hurt! It also depended on which teacher was administering the strap. Some were more ‘effective’ than others. During my first four years at St Joseph’s I received my fair share of strappings, and there was a memorable one during Year 4.
My home class teacher was Mr Joyce (first name unknown or not remembered) who taught French. During Year 3 I had represented the school in an inter-school quiz broadcast to the local hospitals. We lost in the Final to a local girls’ grammar school!
Anyway, one afternoon, Mr Joyce explained that he would hold a quiz to identify promising candidates for the next season’s team. Since I’d already participated, I didn’t take this seriously, and started chatting with the person next to me. We had double desk. Joyce warned me twice to stop talking, but I persisted. On the third warning, he took out his strap, told me to hold out my hand, reached across the desk, and hit me twice across the palm on that fleshy part just below the thumb.
Yes, it hurt but not unduly. However, as I reached for my pen, I suddenly felt dizzy, and the next thing I found myself trying to drag myself off the floor. I’d passed out, and as I fell off my seat, hit my head on the wall to the side. My classmates were shocked. Needless to say, Mr Joyce never touched me again.
We took corporal punishment for granted. Did it have any lasting effect? Probably not for the majority of pupils. But you can never deny that for some of us, it was unduly cruel.
However, it was this flagrant recourse to corporal punishment that lead to me rejecting Catholicism, indeed any formal religion.
When I was in the Upper Sixth (the year immediately prior to heading off to university), Brother Baylor joined the staff (maybe a year earlier). But I’d had no contact with him until then. Anyway, he took us for a formal religion study period once or twice a week. On this particular day, in he came to the classroom and, struggling to peer over his desk (he was a tiny man), told us that we would be doing some Bible studies that day. And, removing his leather strap from its ‘holster’, and lightly tapping it across his hand, told us in a threatening tone, that we would believe else he would strap us.
It was like a light bulb going off in my head. I realized that if a ‘man of God’ had to make threats such as this, there couldn’t be much to sustain the foundation of his beliefs. And from that day I refused to attend Sunday Mass; I went through the motions at school as there were services we had to attend. I’ve not been to Mass since, and never will. The Catholic Church lost one of its flock. I guess I started out as agnostic, but this has become hardened over the years into contented atheism.
As I mentioned earlier, I was quite horrified to read those sad commentaries about St Mary’s. It’s not a situation I recognize since I did not experience it. It’s as though the nuns had Jekyll and Hyde personalities. That does not however diminish the impact of those unhappy years on some members of the St Mary’s community in the 1950s and 60s.
This feedback comes at a time when the Catholic Church is under ever closer scrutiny not only about child sex abuse, but also wider abuse of children for which some of the incidents related on that Facebook page might legitimately be considered. If not abuse as such, it was certainly bordering on abuse in my opinion. ‘Official’ violence against small children would not be tolerated in schools today. Yes, it was another era but that should not, and cannot, excuse such behavior.
I moved on. I’ve had a fruitful career and happy life. But a simple Facebook request has brought so many memories flooding back, not only for me but all those who read it, that I could not pass another day without committing my thoughts in this post.
I am amazed you have grown up to be an atheist, you always seemed such a good catholic boy. I myself am not a practising catholic, but do believe in God. I would describe myself as spiritual.
I remember the nuns’ being strict,. Mother Bernadine would say ‘I shall come down upon you like an of bricks’ and she would roll up your sleeve and smack your forearm hard. Mother Elizabeth was the one nun who would use the cane. I understand that they lived by such a strict code of discipline themselves they probably did not see their treatment o e children as being especially harsh. Mr. Smith though, he was different. Quite cruel I thought. I could go on with my memories, ubhave no wish to bore you, however I do know quite a ol about what happened do some of our classmates so if you would like to chat some more do let me know.
Shirley Birch (nee Pearson)
I am very disturbed by the whole set up at St Josephs. I was regularly strapped by the Christian Buggers and I still have some very disturbing memories of incidents that occurred. Too late to bring them to justice as they are probably all dead. However I did read of one case where an abused pupil dug up the grave of an offending cleric and smashed his skull to bits. What happened to this boy to make him act so extremely? i think you were the year above me. Were you a prefect at some stage? If you were it was a safe thing to do. I remember being verbally abused as much as physical. The number of sexual abuse cases coming to light now is quite disturbing. I can understand why you are a contented atheist. Some of the men were downright evil. RSVP
Thanks for your comments, John. Yes, I was a prefect during 1966-67 (I left St Joseph’s in the summer of 1967), the same year that Stephen Harrison and David Miller were Head Boy and Deputy, respectively. I was never aware of any sexual abuse taking place during the seven years I attended St Joseph’s. In latter year I was friendly with Fr Tolkien, but never was aware/or experienced any of the dealings he has been accused of. However, the CBs and lay staff were all too quick, at the least provocation, to reach for the leather strap. This was excessive. On reflection, I don’t think I received a good education at St Joseph’s, and I might have prospered better if I had remained in Leek for high school. Apart from one or two teachers, the teaching standards were not very high.
Being another ex-inmate of St Joseph’s, Trent Vale (1969 – 1976), I read this with heightened interest, you may have known my Brother. I too have many anecdotes of unfairly administered corporal punishment and astonishing feats of hypocrisy, but I balance it with the fact that, like you, I am able to express myself and reap the benefit of a lucrative and interesting career due to my education. In common with about 85% of old boys of the era, I too lost my Religion. Then one day it occurred to me that Jesus was not a Catholic. Christianity is not about ritual and the strictly enforced rules that were beaten into us, quite the reverse. It is a philosophy of forgiveness, compassion and people sitting around a table together enjoying food and convivial company. Not that you would think so if you look at its history in the hands of men since the Resurrection, (including the CBs) but it was meant to be so, according to the Man Himself. I never encountered sexual abuse at St Joe’s, but I heard plenty about it from Catholic Priests on the National News. Its not enough to shout at the telly and call Catholics names, so I enrolled as a voluntary Safeguarding Officer at a local Church to defend the defenceless, but in five years or so, happily, I never encountered anything untoward. My intent here is only to share another experience of St Joe’s and where it lead me – One Lay Teacher once said of the CBs, “They are not Brothers and they are certainly not Christian”. I think he got it right. R.I.P. Crab Collins, Fideliter et Fortiter.
Dear Jim, Thanks for your comment. One of my friends was Philip Jamieson (known as Jamie) who lived in Swynnerton, if memory serves me correctly. Crab Collins – memories. I knew his daughter Clare quite well.
I started in prep school in 1966, teachers there were Tom Byrne and a blonde woman called Engel… her German husband taught music among other things. On the whole they were reasonably normal unlike the Irish thug brothers who I’d best describe as obsessive manic lunatics concerned only i teaching sports. By far the worst one was a tallish bald headed hypocrite who went by the name of Brother Dwan, his trade mark was to grip boys by their cheeks using his fingers and thumb with a violent pinching force and shake their heads from side to side whilst breathing down on them with bad breath. I don’t think he even knew how to clean himself or use a toothbrush as he stunk of a combination of tobacco and body odour. In those days teachers smoking in class was a normal activity. If Dwan was alive today he would certainly be liable for prosecution from the law. I learnt nothing of any significance throughout my time there and left their asylum in 1971.As you can gauge from my most uncomplimentary tone I too have no respect for that place and as for Dwan he can go rot in Hell for all I care about the idiot.